Four Vie to Become St. Charles Mayor
A guide to the April 2013 mayoral race pitting a political freshman and three newcomers.
This race started early, as far as St. Charles’ municipal elections go, when Mayor Donald DeWitte announced in late August 2012 that he would not seek a third term as mayor.
The announcement marked the beginning of a campaign that has become centered largely on whether the mayor and council are responsive to residents. Much of that contention was brought on by two key council votes related to the controversial Lexington Club development. A City Council committee voted to reject a tax-increment financing plan for the project in December, but then in early January, approved not only a revised TIF agreement, but the entire project on a tie 5-5 vote broken by DeWitte, a longtime supporter of the plan.
If the Lexington project had been controversial before, what appeared to be a sudden reversal fanned the flames of anger among a very vocal group of people who had opposed the development. That anger has framed much of the public discussion on the campaign.
A key question, however: Just how large a group, and how widespread is the anger over Lexington Club?
Raymond Rogina, midway through his first term as 3rd Ward alderman and the first to enter the mayoral race, was one of the five alderman voting against the project. John Rabchuk, an entrepreneurial businessman, is the only candidate to speak in favor of Lexington Club. He also came out early in support of the city’s 2013 draft Comprehensive Master Plan, which has drawn scrutiny and criticism from Lexington Club opponents.
The anger has some residents complaining bitterly that the aldermen and mayor ignored their voices and are defying the “will of the people” in favor of developers.
That has prompted several candidates to focus on the city's communication with residents as an issue of its own. One of these is retired Army Col. Jake Wyatt, whose campaign announcement in late November focused on on his business experience and expressed concern about the present state of affairs in St. Charles. Since then, Wyatt, Rogina and Rabchuk have focused on the importance of being accessible — and listening to — St. Charles residents.
While the fallout from Lexington Club has the potential to have a large impact on the April 9 election, it is far from the only issue at hand. Still, it might be frustrating for candidates focused on other issues to be heard over the din.
Attorney and author Jotham Stein has focused his campaign on property taxes and, more so, on economic development. Amid all the outcry on Lexington Club and voter representation issues, he largely has ignored Lexington Club-related issues to focus on economic development. Stein says the city needs to do more to attract new businesses to St. Charles. He says that not only will new businesses fill up empty storefronts in town, they also would direct more tax revenues into city coffers and allow the city to cut property tax rates.
Early voting begins March 25. Election Day is April 9. As the campaign continues, we will continue to post links to related stories.
Candidate Announcements, Bios
Bio & issues: About Raymond P. Rogina
- Sept. 14, 2012: Rogina Announces Run for St. Charles Mayor
Bio & issues: About Jotham Stein
- Oct. 15, 2012: Jotham Stein Announces St. Charles Mayoral Bid
Bio & issues: About John Rabchuk
- Oct. 18, 2012: John Rabchuk Enters St. Charles Mayoral Race
Bio & issues: About Jake ‘Wayne’ Wyatt
- Nov. 30, 2012: Jake Wyatt Becomes 4th St. Charles Mayoral Contender
The ‘Must-Read’ Stories
- Aug. 31, 2012:Mayor DeWitte Won’t Seek Third Term
- Sept. 1, 2012:Analysis: Who Would Be St. Charles Mayor?
- Nov. 18, 2012: Rabchuk Endorses St. Charles Draft 2013 Comprehensive Plan
- Nov. 18, 2012:Alderman Rogina: Plan Endorsement Premature
- Nov. 20, 2012:Mayoral Candidate Critical of Tax Levy as an Increase
- Dec. 10, 2012:St. Charles Aldermen Kill Corporate Reserve, Lexington Club
- Dec. 18, 2012:Mayoral Candidate Decries St. Charles ‘Tax Rate Increase’
- Jan. 3, 2013:Rabchuk Suggests St. Charles Aldermen Reconsider Lexington Club Vote
- Jan. 7, 2013:St. Charles Shocker: Council OKs Lexington Club
- Jan. 7, 2013:Review Jan. 7 Live-Blog Coverage of St. Charles Council
- Feb. 17, 2013: Rogina Outlines Vision for St. Charles Central Business District Renewal
- Feb. 19, 2013: Stein, Rabchuk: Rogina's Downtown St. Charles Plan Not Enough
Election Forums
- April 3, 2013: Review Live-Blog Coverage of the April 3 Mayoral, School Board Candidates Forum
- March 28, 2013:Review Live-Blog Coverage of the March 28 St. Charles Mayoral Forum
- March 12, 2013: Review the March 12 St. Charles Mayoral Forum Live-Blog Coverage
More Local Election Coverage on Patch
- St. Charles Election Central: A guide to every race that affects residents of St. Charles will be posted by mid-February.
- St. Charles City Council: Catch up on what the City Council has been doing before you vote.
New to Patch?
- Join Patch! Create a free user account and join the discussion about the future of St. Charles. You’ll be subscribed to the free daily newsletter and breaking news alerts.
- Got a news tip? Email St. Charles Patch editor Ted Schnell.
Take the Patch Mayoral Poll
Registered users of St. Charles Patch can cast a vote in our ongoing straw poll.
Vanessa Bell-LaSota
8:09 am on Saturday, March 9, 2013
Jake Wyatt is the most qualified candidate, fresh, friendly, positive, well-balanced, prepared to lead. He will build consensus through a transparent process, not by bullying or calling in favors. Jake will expect and motivate the best effort from City staff and Council. He will respect the contributions from residents, business owners. He has met with every single City department-often for more than two hours! He has attended every Commission, Committee, Board, Task Force we have. Jake has sought out resident comments at Coffee With Jake every Saturday 9:30-noon at Amer. Legion Post 342 11500 N. 5th Ave. Come meet Jake. St Charles needs Jake Wyatt.
RONALD JOHNSON
2:16 pm on Saturday, March 9, 2013
Jake Wyatt is what this city needs at this time more than anything. As a successful businessman and military officer he has the most important traits needed to run the city. Commitment, honor, dedication,an understanding of budgets and common sense spending and a love of this country and St. Charles.
josephine s.
8:46 am on Sunday, March 10, 2013
The way I see it, looking at his website, I went to his "Meet Jake" this past Saturday at with a friend at the Am. Legion....Wyatt's 3 point plan is informed, makes sense, comsiders the scope of the Mayor's powers but also realizes there are opportunities for a real leader to improve how and when decisions are made.in St Charles. He has the "how to" experiece to back up everything he says-not the "we should" or "I wish" or "I will" generalities I'm reading from the others, that just don't add up. He;s a proven leader and strategist. ( No disrerspect but,) not a teacher, a committee appointee, litigator. That is what I like about Jake,
Rich Swenson
9:08 am on Sunday, March 10, 2013
The issue it seems with Mr. Wyatt just may be he is too much like we have had with our current leadership. His 'top down' leadership where everything comes from him and everyone below is expected to fall in line and execute his orders is fine in the Military life, but not in City Politics. It completely stops the creation and openess for others to have ideas and suggestions because it appears it's what he feels is right and thus nobody else's vision matters. That is exactly what we have right now and it is not working. The best way to the best solution is to be able to bounce ideas and listen. NO ONE PERSON is that perfect or knows everything about everything. His idea of leadership is too narrow minded. Like I said, St. Charles in not the Gulf War, and who is to say his vision is the end all and that everyone wants what he wants....that's very different that having one goal of winning a war. Another tell tale sign was at the forum when asked what was you biggest failure, for him it wasn't that he ever himself failed, his story was about picking the wrong business partner, so he felt he has never made any mistakes in life or business? Come On Now!
Gene Kalley
9:24 pm on Sunday, March 10, 2013
I believe it was Rabchuk that said he picked the wrong partner.
josephine s.
11:44 pm on Sunday, March 10, 2013
Thomas, you are referring to John Rabchuk. That's r-a-b-c-h-u-k. He said that. Come on now, yourself!
Steve Swanson
9:59 pm on Sunday, March 10, 2013
None of the candidates is a perfect candidate--they all have their pluses and minuses. But when I look at the big picture, I see Wyatt as being the best of the bunch. He is the only one who has committed so publicly to be available to citizens to answer questions and to get their opinions than the others.
josephine s.
11:42 pm on Sunday, March 10, 2013
Thomas R- BOY have you got it backwards. Where were you sitting? BOTH Rogina and Stein said "it starts from the top down", NOT Wyatt. You are way off-base. Wyatt said "it starts from the ground up, with residents & local businesses getting a voice via the two forums he'll hold-he will be a full-time Mayor. Mondays anyone can talk to him for 10 minutes,( or more, if less people show up,) at every Saturday he will continue the "Meet Jake" at the American Legion, monthly, he'll hold a resident's forum, (more, if necessary) and also will institute a business owners/industrial forum to improve what the Chamber has in place, a quarterly meeting w/the taxing bodies. How is that "top-down" thinking? And RABCHUK said he chose the wrong business partner- please get your facts straight before you comment & mislead others who were not there and did not hear. About the Gulf War, reference what disrespect. He managed a 57B budget from 33 Coalition Nations. He knows how to work with people, move plans forward by bulding consensus, not forcing votes,ignoring public sentiment & concerns of local business. He has worked across the country with many city administrations. Not just "talking to mayors in other cities" like Rogina said he has done, that evening, Jake Wyatt has worked with mayors in many other cities.
Jake will change the feeling of censure &
fear and discouragement
of speaking out in this town with his open door.
Tony C.
9:24 am on Wednesday, March 13, 2013
Totally objective point of view after attending the mayoral forum w/ no horse in this race.
Ray Rogina: A steady hand in understanding the community needs & how the current system works. Safe choice...
John Rabchuk: Clearly the biggest thinker w/ new ideas for the future of the city. Turning the city into a lifestyle, cultural, health/wellness & athletic hub could really spur solid growth opportunities for the city to have a new identity...Good pick...
Jake Wyatt: Straight shooter, would do an admirable job w/ hands on approach & building strong internal community relationships to move the city forward w/ a methodical approach...Good man...Solid pick...
Jotham Stein: He simply is not the right person for this huge undertaking. Self centered, egotistical & condescending...just not a fit for the challenges ahead for this community. Poor people skills & would be very devisive. Not the right choice...
Patrick
4:29 pm on Tuesday, March 19, 2013
Tony:
I am confused how Rabchuk is "the biggest thinker w/new ideas for the future of the city"??? The only ideas i have heard are for a bike hub and a manipulation of the Fox River--please. Wyatt merely advocates for forums. These are not ideas. This is not leadership. Rogina begins from day one-ready to lead. A proven leader. An alderman with council support-ready to govern. He has many ideas from a downtown revival to dealing with the bars and beyond. He is my horse.
Vanessa Bell-LaSota
10:42 am on Wednesday, March 20, 2013
Patrick,
Leadership is a team effort requiring discernment and experience. Ideas are a part, not the whole. Jake Wyatt has more experience than the other candidates, and it comes from a deep understanding of what is possible, what is not. Idle promises without the mechanics are not leadership. Like the idea of lowering taxes from Stein .The city only controls 11%-the taxing bodies control the rest-a forum for the 8 taxing bodies is a constructive IDEA, never seen before, not an empty promise. Wyatt is the only candidate advocating for listening first, willing to admit his priorities are to first do what is necessary to support, secure current local businesses,not force his agenda. The "how -to" is immediate and key at this time in our City's fiscal future-nice ideas are not going to preserve & conserve. Wyatt isn't willing to say anything just to garner votes, and that is courageous. Rabchuk, Rogina are derivative of current administration. Jake's four forums grew from his active interest, feedback he got from residents, business owners, local industry, that they are not heard or asked. That is leadership. He has met w/every city department, every commission-many for over 2 hours...listening, asking, assessing. Rogina's parroted "Arcada rose" cultural emphasis downtown is a shared desire among the candidates, has been discussed for years . Rabchuk's "city branding" grew from the Comp Plan community workshops, the Task Force panel he was appointed to by Mayor DeWitte.